Is it wrong to pick up a dungeon filler list? This question often arises among role-playing game (RPG) enthusiasts, particularly when they are preparing for an extended campaign. Dungeon filler lists, also known as “filler content,” are collections of encounters, side quests, and other non-essential content designed to bridge the gaps between major plot points in a campaign. While some argue that using these lists can detract from the immersive experience, others believe they are a valuable tool for keeping the game flowing smoothly. In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of using dungeon filler lists and help you decide whether they are right for your gaming group.
The primary purpose of a dungeon filler list is to provide a sense of continuity and progression in a campaign without the need for extensive plot development. These lists often include encounters with various creatures, puzzles, and challenges that can keep players engaged and entertained. Proponents of using dungeon filler lists argue that they:
1. Save time: Crafting unique encounters for every single game session can be time-consuming. Dungeon filler lists offer a convenient way to add variety and depth to your campaign without the need for meticulous planning.
2. Encourage exploration: Filler content can lead players to explore areas of the world they might not have visited otherwise, enriching the overall experience.
3. Provide balance: By including a mix of encounters, you can ensure that the game remains challenging and engaging for players of different skill levels.
However, there are also valid concerns about the use of dungeon filler lists:
1. Lack of originality: Some players argue that using pre-made filler content can make the game feel less unique and less tailored to your group’s preferences.
2. Potential for predictability: If the encounters in the filler list are too common or too predictable, they may detract from the suspense and excitement of the game.
3. Over-reliance on the GM: Some players feel that using a dungeon filler list can make the game too reliant on the Game Master (GM) to provide interesting and engaging content.
Ultimately, whether it is wrong to pick up a dungeon filler list depends on your personal preferences and the expectations of your gaming group. If you and your friends enjoy the convenience and variety that filler content offers, then using a dungeon filler list may be the right choice for you. However, if you prefer to create unique and original content for each session, you may want to avoid relying on pre-made lists.
In conclusion, the decision to use a dungeon filler list should be based on what works best for your gaming group. While some may argue that it is wrong to use such lists, others will find them to be a valuable resource for maintaining a smooth and enjoyable game experience. Remember that the most important aspect of any RPG is having fun, so choose the approach that allows you and your friends to do so.
