What was wrong with dad in “If” by Rudyard Kipling is a poignant question that resonates with readers across generations. This classic poem explores the complexities of a father-son relationship and delves into the hidden struggles that dad faces. In this article, we will examine the various aspects of dad’s problems and how they shape the narrative of the poem.
The poem begins with the question, “What was wrong with dad in if?” This immediate inquiry sets the stage for a deeper exploration of dad’s character and his challenges. One of the primary issues that dad faces is his struggle with his own self-doubt and insecurities. He questions his worth and fears that he is not living up to the expectations of his son. This internal conflict is evident in the poem’s opening lines:
What was wrong with dad in if,
If he were not the son of a king?
Dad’s insecurities stem from his lack of confidence in his own abilities and his perceived shortcomings. He believes that he is not measuring up to the standards set by his royal lineage, which adds an extra layer of pressure to his already fragile self-esteem.
Another significant problem with dad in the poem is his struggle with his role as a father. He is depicted as a man who is disconnected from his son, failing to provide the guidance and support that a child needs. This disconnect is further compounded by dad’s own personal struggles, which prevent him from being fully present in his son’s life. The poem highlights this issue through the following lines:
What was wrong with dad in if,
If he were not the son of a king?
The question “What was wrong with dad in if?” also serves as a commentary on the societal expectations placed on men, particularly those in positions of power. Dad’s struggle with his identity and his role as a father reflect the broader challenges that men face in society. The poem suggests that dad’s problems are not unique to him but are instead part of a larger struggle that many men encounter.
Moreover, the poem addresses the issue of mental health and the stigma that often surrounds it. Dad’s internal battles with his self-worth and his relationship with his son can be seen as a metaphor for the silent suffering that many individuals experience. The poem encourages readers to confront these issues and to seek help when needed.
In conclusion, the question “What was wrong with dad in ‘If'” serves as a gateway to understanding the complexities of the father-son relationship and the hidden struggles that dad faces. The poem delves into issues of self-doubt, the pressure of societal expectations, and the challenges of fatherhood. By examining these aspects, “If” provides a timeless and thought-provoking perspective on the human condition.
