What do Catholics think of the movie “Conclave”? This question has sparked a range of opinions and discussions among the faithful, as the film delves into the intrigue and secrecy surrounding the election of a new Pope. “Conclave” is a 2016 political thriller directed by Paul Verhoeven, based on the novel of the same name by Mario Puzo, who is also known for writing “The Godfather.” The movie portrays the process of electing a new Pope amidst a backdrop of political maneuvering, personal vendettas, and the Catholic Church’s internal struggles. In this article, we will explore the various perspectives of Catholics on this controversial film.
Some Catholics appreciate the film for its portrayal of the Conclave’s procedures and the complexity of the decision-making process. They argue that “Conclave” offers a realistic look into the inner workings of the Catholic Church, highlighting the importance of unity and tradition within the faith. These viewers see the movie as an opportunity to educate themselves on the Church’s history and the significance of the Papacy.
However, many Catholics are critical of the film’s depiction of the Conclave. They argue that “Conclave” perpetuates stereotypes and portrays the Catholic Church in a negative light. Critics point out that the movie’s portrayal of the Cardinals as power-hungry and corrupt is a misrepresentation of the Church’s true values and the dedication of its members. Additionally, some viewers find the film’s portrayal of the sexual tension between characters to be inappropriate and offensive.
Another concern among Catholics is the film’s portrayal of the election process itself. Some believe that “Conclave” downplays the importance of prayer, faith, and divine intervention in the election of a new Pope. They argue that the movie focuses too much on the political aspect of the Conclave, neglecting the spiritual dimension that is central to the Church’s mission.
Despite the criticism, there are also Catholics who appreciate “Conclave” for its thought-provoking content and the questions it raises about the future of the Catholic Church. They argue that the film encourages viewers to reflect on the Church’s role in modern society and the challenges it faces. These viewers see the movie as a conversation starter, inviting discussions on the importance of transparency and accountability within the Church.
In conclusion, the movie “Conclave” has sparked a diverse range of opinions among Catholics. While some appreciate its portrayal of the Conclave’s procedures and the film’s thought-provoking content, others are critical of its negative portrayal of the Catholic Church and the stereotypes it perpetuates. Ultimately, the film serves as a catalyst for conversations about the Church’s past, present, and future, prompting Catholics to consider their own beliefs and values in light of its controversial narrative.
